Sewing: not women’s work

You’ve probably heard the story: a well-known retailer stuck a poorly-worded label in some of its school uniform. The label suggested the reinforced hems in its clothing would stay in place making “less work for mum” who wouldn’t have to sew them up again.

sewing, sew, anguage, gender equality, equality, feminism,

Photographic evidence that men can sew. Photo credit: Vignesh Morthy.

It was a very poor, ill-advised choice of language. It was wrong to assume that the responsibility for sewing and school uniforms falls on mum’s shoulders.

It’s the kind of sentiment that suggests someone hasn’t caught up with the realities of twenty-first century life. You know, with almost 10% of single parent families being headed by men and same sex families having been openly raising kids for a long time.

Added to this, all the anecdotal evidence suggests us stay at home fathers are increasing in numbers. No, sewing is not simply a job for mum.

With a background in PR and communications, I was very surprised a high-street store would use such labelling, but I couldn’t get hugely worked up about this issue. Well, not until I saw my daughter’s reaction but I’m coming on to that.

In the greater scheme of things, both genders face considerably bigger challenges than a poorly-worded label. Boys’ ever decreasing academic achievement and a US President with scant regard for women’s rights are two issues that dwarf the issue of a clothes label.

Yet it’s not quite that simple. I happened to be reading a news article about this seemingly minor scandal on my phone. I handed it over to Helen, my eight year old daughter, so she could read the story for herself.

My aims were two-fold. Firstly to see if she could read and comprehend the news story. Secondly, I was curious to see if she had an opinion on it.

Well she certainly could read and comprehend that news story. In fact her reaction caught me quite by surprise, proving that she had a very strong opinion.

Helen screwed up her face and declared “That’s not fair, daddy’s can sew too.”

You maybe had to have witnessed Helen’s reaction to fully appreciate it, but she clearly felt this was a great injustice. Helen only pulls that face when she is very upset.

As my wife works full time and I do the majority of the childcare, our kids are raised in a very gender-aware household. Mrs Adams and I are always very careful in how we talk to the kids so we don’t limit their ambition or ideas. Incidentally, they’ve seen me sewing many a time, considerably more than their mother.

This will have been one of the first overt cases of sexism Helen came up against. It’s perhaps no great surprise she found it upsetting, more so as she’s a kid with an incredibly strong sense of fair-play.

Perhaps my views were polarised because of International Women’s Day. On seeing Helen’s reaction, I felt that maybe there was more to this than a badly-worded label. It sends out a very poor message to young girls and boys, some of whom will inevitably have read that label. I will also add that, as a stay at home dad, I regularly refuse to purchase items that are labelled in such a way as I am deeply uncomfortable with the idea that parenting is women’s responsibility.

I’ve long held the belief that language is everything. This episode has made me realise just how influential it can be on young minds.

Have you had a similar experience with your children? At what age do you think children start picking up on such things. Please do leave a comment below, I’d be very interested to hear of your experiences.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

6 Comments

  1. March 9, 2017 / 6:46 am

    I basically have no time for the “Aren’t there bigger things to worry about in the world” argument. It generally shows that the issue raised has merit. Also, it can conceivably be levelled at any issue or problem in the world. It’s possible to care for those ‘big’ problems and the ‘little’ ones to – not least because all the little ones can easily add up to big ones anyway.

    • John Adams
      Author
      March 9, 2017 / 2:47 pm

      Yup, and I won’t deny it: I should have been upset by that label. Truth is I was, but as a stay at home dad, such examples are Legion. If I let every single one get to me, my life would be quite miserable! Seeing Helen’s reaction, however, has persuaded me to start calling this stuff out more often.

  2. March 9, 2017 / 7:07 am

    You’re absolutely right that this matters because children see it. A label might not seem like a big deal but it’s another part of the slow drip that forms our cultural expectations of gender roles. It’s great that your daughter had enough evidence to see that this is nonsense, sadly not many kids will have seen the same evidence in their own families. Well done on setting good role models in your family, this post has got me thinking about how we can do similar in our family when I’m the stay at home parent.

    • John Adams
      Author
      March 9, 2017 / 2:46 pm

      Thakns Bec. I’m glad you enjoyed the post and I hope you look out for unconscious bias in your own family and beyond.

  3. Sue Barsby
    March 9, 2017 / 7:19 am

    John, I should point out that there are tons of adverts and marketing copy that like to tell us they ‘make things easier for mums.’ It infuriates me that in this day and age women are rarely acknowledged beyond their caring duties which, as you point out, are no longer solely theirs. However it does reinforce a greater point, which is that even in two parent heteroesexual families with two working parents, women will still do much of this stuff. Men and boys are socialised differently. I know many men who are willing to do their share the burden and who do great things but if you examined it, you’d still find their wives did more. I also see this in my nephew and how he is raised. In many ways some of this is unconscious, which is why we need to call out the obvious stuff like this when we see it.

    Sorry to rant.

    • John Adams
      Author
      March 9, 2017 / 2:45 pm

      My word. Well I know where you won’t go shopping for school uniform any time soon. I totally agree with you and I know I should have been very bothered by this example. The truth is, there is so much “small” stuff out there that if I let every single one get to me, i’d be in a constant state of anger. I’m probably more aware of it because of the swapped gender roles in my family. My daughter having reacted to vehemently on this occasion, I feel the need to get back on the horse and make more of a fuss when these things happen in future. It’s been quite inspiring, albeit for the wrong reasons.